|
¡̃ Background
In November 2004, when trade ministries from Korea and the U.S. held a meeting in Chile, both parties agreed to pursue the possibility of US-Korea FTA negotiations.
Between February and April of 2004, both governments met three times to examine the feasibility of the US-Korea FTA, while the trade ministers of both countries held 6 meetings to further examine the initiation of bilateral FTA negotiations.
At a meeting held on the sidelines of another APEC (Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation) summit in Chile in November of 2005, President Roh and President Bush confirmed their willingness to push forward with US-Korea FTA talk. Finally, on February 3, 2006, both countries formally announced the launching of official US-Korea FTA negotiation.
Since the announcement, the US and Korea have had several joint preliminary meetings aimed at tuning up the formal FTA talk. On March 6, and April 17-18, both governments met off-the-record in conference to prepare for the actual negotiations.
Through these meetings, they agreed to include 17 disputed sectors in the initial round and to adopt "KORUS FTA" as the official name of the agreement. On May 19, the two countries exchanged drafts of the initial proposals to be discussed during the first round of the FTA talks.
The US and Korea have agreed that they will release the final joint agreement to the public immediately after completion, but they will not reveal any other documents generated during the negotiation process for the next three years.
¡̃ Schedule
The goal in the current FTA negotiations between Korea and the U.S., set when the matter was first brought up in February of this year, is to conclude the negotiations by the end of the year.
There are five rounds of US-Korea FTA talks scheduled for 2006. The first talk is happening in Washington DC from June 5 to 9. The objective of the first round of talks is to simply examine the initial drafts and understand each country's position and intentions concerning sensitive issues, rather than press each other to prematurely arrive at a conclusion.
Both parties are likely to discuss simple issues first and set aside areas of special interest for further discussion in later talks.
The substantial discussion on conflicting issues regarding goods, capital and, services will be primarily dealt with during the 2nd round of FTA talks, which will be held July 10-14 in Seoul. Three more rounds are currently scheduled for September (Washington), October (Seoul), and December (Washington).
< schedule chart >
| 1st Round |
June 5-9 2006 |
Washington DC |
| 2nd Round |
July 10-14, 2006 |
Seoul, Korea |
| 3rd Round |
September 2006 |
Washington DC |
| 4th Round |
October 2006 |
Seoul, Korea |
| 5th Round |
December 2006 |
Washington DC |
¡̃ Negotiation Teams
The Korean negotiation team is composed of 80 delegates from the trading negotiation department within the Ministry of Foreign Affair and Trade and about 60 additional officials from various government offices related to commerce and trade.
The US has a negotiation team of nearly 170 representatives, which outnumbers the Korean team. The chief Korean negotiator Kim Jong-hoon commented that, "Since the negotiations are taking place in Washington DC, it is expected that the US government will benefit from the home ground advantage."
Nothing describes the Korean negotiation team better than 'the Trading Dream Team,' considering each member of the team is a well-known trade expert or experienced official in his or her field.
< Negotiation Teams >
| Sector |
Korea |
United States |
| Chief Negotiator |
Kim Jong-hoon, Chief Negotiator |
Wendy Cutler, Assistant US Trade Representative |
| MA/NT |
Lee Hye-min, Chief Director for FTA |
Tiffany Smith, Director of Tariff Affairs |
| Agriculture |
Bae Jong-ha, Senior Director for International Agriculture |
Andrew Stephens, Director of Bilateral Agricultural Affairs |
| Textile |
Kim Soon-chul, Director for Textile and Fashion/td>
| Caroyl Miller, Deputy Textile Negotiator |
| Country of Origin / Customs Clearance Process |
Kim Jong-bum, Director for FTA Product Negotiation Jun Joon-hong, Director for Custom Affairs |
JJay Eizenstat, Director for Custom Affairs |
| Trade Protection |
Sim Dong-sub, Director for Investigation Lee Won-tae, Director for Custom Policy Kim Kyung-han, Director for Trade Strategy |
|
SPS (Sanitary & Phytosanitary) |
Jung Hyun-chool, Director for FTA2 |
Cathy Enright, Director for Sanitary & Phytosanitary Measures |
TBT (Technical Barriers to Trade) |
Lee Choong-ho, Director for Global Standards |
Suzanne Troje, Director for Technical Barriers to Trade |
| Investment |
Choi Kyung-lim, Senior Negotiator for FTA Kim Pil-gu, Director for Investment |
Amber Cottle, DAUSTR for Investment |
| Service |
Kim Young-mo, Director for Arbitration of Trade Yoo Myung-hee, Director for FTA Service Negotiation |
Chris Melly, Director for Service Trade Negotiation |
| Financial Service |
Sin Jae-yoon, International Finance Investigator |
Kimberly Claman, Senior Director Investment Affairs Treasury: TBD |
Telecommunications / Electronic Commerce |
Nam Young-sook, Secondary Negotiator for FTA Jung Dong-hee, Director for Electronic Commerce |
Jonathan Mchale, Director for Telecommunications Trade Policy & Electronic Commerce |
| Competition |
Kim Jong-bum, Director for FTA Product Negotiation Jang Deuk-soo, Director for International Corporation |
Stu Chemtob, Special Counsel for International Trade Antitrust Division, DOJ Scott Ki, Senior Director for Korea |
| Government Procurement |
Ahn Myung-soo, Law Officer for Trade Jang Hoon-ki, Director for Accounting System |
Jean Grier, Senior Procurement Negotiator |
| Intellectual Property Rights |
Lee Gun-tae, Senior Director for Local Trade Park Min-kwan, Director for Intellectual Property |
Jennifer Choe-Groves, Director for Intellectual Property |
| Labor |
Park Suk-bum, Senior Director for International Economy Lee Myung-ro, Director for International Negotiation |
Lewis Karesh, AUSTR for Labor |
| Environment |
Park Suk-bum, Senior Director for International Economy |
Russell Smith, Director for International Environmental Policy & Multilateral Environmental Agreements |
| Arbitrage / Transparency / Provisions |
Kim Won-kyung, Director for FTA Local Negotiation |
Jim Kelleher, Associate General Counsel |
| Automobile |
Kim Hau- yong, Investigator for Local Trade Kim Young-min, Director for Transportation Technology |
Scott Ki, Senior Director for Korea |
| Pharmaceuticals / Medical Provisions |
Jun Man-bok, Senior Director for FTA T/F |
Arrow Augerot, DAUSTR for Korea Tom Bollyky, Director Asia-Pacific & Pharmaceutical Policy |
¡̃ Key Differences
As the FTA talks began today in Washington, Korea and the United States will face some challenges in reaching an agreement because of differences in priorities.
This first round of talks will cover 17 sectors of trade, including agriculture, financial services, medicine, education, legal and accounting services, broadcasting and advertising, government procurement, and utilities such as electricity, gas, and tapped water.
Although both countries wish to complete these negotiations successfully, Korea and the US have very different opinions about several key issues, as each has its own demands and wishes regarding various sectors.
Regarding agricultural trade, the US wants to open the Korean market completely for all agriculture products. However, Korea wishes to protect its domestic agricultural market by imposing a special tariff on key products such as rice, chicken, tobacco, and apples.
Korea especially desires this safeguard as they have already raised its rice import quota from 4 to 7.96 percent of total domestic consumption under a deal made in the 2004 World Trade Organization.
Another point of conflict has to do with automobile trade. The US wants Korea to remove key tariffs on imported US vehicles, but Korea plans to maintain such tariffs, as automobile tax is a key source of revenue for their local governments.
The U.S. also wants Korea to remove all tariffs on pharmaceutical and medical equipment, but Korea says they only want to open up these markets in varying degrees by selected items.
On the other hand, Korea wants the U.S. to recognize those products manufactured in Gaesong, North Korea as Korean goods, but the US refuses to accept Gaeseong products as made in Korea.
Korea also requests the US to allow a new quota of visas for Korean workers, but the US says no.
< 17 Sectors to be discussed during Korea-U.S. FTA Talks >
| Sectors |
Content |
| Merchandise Trade |
Reduce/remove merchandise tariffs including automobiles, pharmaceuticals, and medical equipment, etc. (excluding farm products) |
| Trade Protection Policy |
Anti-dumping, compensation for tariffs and subsidies, other safeguards, etc. |
| Agricultural Industry |
Reduce/remove of tariffs and implement safeguards on farm products |
| Textile Industry |
Textile / apparel fields, dispute about textile origin, etc. |
| Source of Manufactured goods/Customs Clearance Process |
Establish criteria for the origin of manufactured goods and simplify customs clearance process |
| Sanitary & Phytosanitary (SPS) |
Sanitation and medical inspection process |
| Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT) |
Technology barriers and validation standards |
| Investment |
Liberalize and protect investment |
| Services |
Liberalize services (excluding finance) and flow of human resources |
| Financial Service |
Financial service issues |
| Telecommunication / Electronic Commercial Transaction |
Telecommunication / electronic commercial transaction fields |
| Competition |
Measures for competition and ways to cooperate among competitive countries |
| Government Procurement |
Plans to liberalize government procurement |
| Intellectual Property Rights |
Intellectual property rights issues, including patent rights, copyrights, trademarks, etc. |
| Labor |
Labor issues |
| Environment |
Environmental issues |
| Arbitrage/Transparency / Provisions |
Arbitrage process, such as interpreting the agreement Increase the transparency of the agreement process |
Furthermore, the US wants the limit on foreign shareholding in the telecommunications industry to be completely removed, but Korea wishes to maintain it. The US demands this because encouraging the selection and dictating the incorporation of Korea's standard technology by Korean industries limit foreign access to Korea's telecommunications sector and other key industries.
Lastly, Korea agrees to partially liberalize the cross-border capital trade, but the US demands a complete liberalization. They want Korea to either fully liberalize its courier services or to improve its business environment in the two sectors so that US firms can provide new financial derivative services in Korea.
Korea's FTA Ambassador Kim Jong-hoon and Assistant US Trade Representative Wendy Cutler will meet for five days, along with about 300 other delegates from Korea and the United States, in efforts of resolving these conflicts of interest between the two nations. Though the FTA drafts are aggressive on both sides, Kim said on Friday that "Our aim is to advance the negotiations so that they can be acceptable for both sides," and Cutler said during a conference call on Monday, "I remain optimistic about our ability to conclude a high-quality, comprehensive agreement¡¦the political will is clearly there on both sides."
Despite such major differences between the desires of the U.S. and those of Korea regarding the foreign trade agreement, hopefully the two countries can work out these differences in order that they can strengthen and not weaken the Korea-US relationship.
After the five-day meeting this week, Korea and the U.S. will meet in Seoul on July 10-14 for the second round of talks, and future meetings have been scheduled for September, October, and December, so as to meet the March 2007 negotiation deadline before President Bush's power to sign trade deals expires on July 1, 2007.
| Korea |
Issue of Conflict |
United States |
| No additional rice market opening/Seeking to protect key agricultural items |
Agricultural Trade |
Complete opening without exceptions by Korea |
| Apply to Korean agricultural industry |
Activating special safeguards |
Adopt for US textiles industry |
| Automobile taxation system is not negotiable |
Automobile trade |
Removal of key tariff items on imported US vehicles |
| Open up markets in varying degrees by items |
Pharmaceutical & medical equipment |
Complete removal of tariffs |
| Should be treated as made-in-Korea goods by the US |
Made-in-Gaeseong products |
Disregard (not negotiable) |
| Limit should be maintained |
Foreign shareholding limit in telecom industry |
Complete removal |
| Permission |
US allotment of new visa quota for Korean workers |
Disregard (not negotiable) |
| Limited liberalization |
Cross-border capital trade |
Complete liberalization |
|